Save
Every year when Halloween comes around, Monster Munch is my go-to snack for something silly and bright that kids actually want to eat. Picture fluffy popcorn all covered in sweet white chocolate, with pretzels, candy corn, goofy candy eyes, and more—everyone dives in and the bowl disappears way quicker than I expect. It’s so much fun and kind of brings out the kid in everyone at the table.
The first time I made this was for my daughter's class fall party and the kids polished it all off in minutes. Now every October we look forward to making a double batch—it’s become a little family tradition.
Fun Ingredients
- Pretzel rods – 1 and a half cups: Snap them in half for bite-sized pieces and some big crunchy bits. Thicker rods add lots of crunch.
- Candy eyes – 2 tablespoons: The goofier the better! Grab the ones with big eyeballs that really pop.
- White candy melts – 1 and a half cups: Melt them down until they're liquidy and smooth, so everything sticks together sweetly. Pick packs that look bright white, not yellowed.
- Sprinkles – half cup: Colorful or shaped ones are great, but make sure they won't run color when wet.
- Popped popcorn – 6 cups: Double check for any rogue unpopped bits so no one cracks a tooth.
- Candy corn – 1 cup: The classic, bright trio of colors keeps it looking festive—pick up a fresh bag so it tastes right.
Easy Steps
- Chill and Break Up:
- Let everything set up at room temp so the candy coating becomes crisp, usually about half an hour. After it's set, snap the crisp clusters apart and scoop them up right off the tray.
- Add Silly Toppers:
- While the surface is still sticky, throw on your sprinkles and push those candy eyes in so they're looking up at you.
- Finish with Drizzle:
- Pour over the melted white candy in fun zigzag streaks. Cover some spots heavier, especially where the candy bits touch the popcorn, so it all sticks.
- Prep Your Tray:
- Spread the popcorn out in one cozy flat layer on a large rimmed baking sheet, making sure it’s fully cool.
- Scatter in the Goodies:
- Drop the snapped pretzels and the candy corn all over the popcorn. Try to get them spread out so each scoop has a little of everything.
- Smooth the Candy Melts:
- Toss the candy melts into a microwave-safe bowl and zap in short spurts, stirring after each one, until it gets glossy and flows super easily.
Save
If I leave out candy corn, my daughter gets dramatic—it’s her top choice, no contest. The first time she got to add the candy eyes, she was laughing so hard she spilled half of it on the floor. It's one of those silly moments we both remember every Halloween now.
How to Store
Keep Monster Munch in a sealed jar or snap-top box, right on the counter, for up to five days. The fridge is a bad idea because moisture will ruin anything crunchy and mess up the candy texture. For a party, I like to line the container with a bit of parchment so you’re not scraping sticky bits.
Switch-Ups
No white candy melts? Try using milk or dark chocolate instead if you want it less sweet or with more color. Gummy worms or mini peanut butter cups are great in place of candy corn. If you need gluten-free, swap in pretzels that fit the bill.
How to Serve
Portion it into little cellophane bags for easy handouts to trick-or-treaters, or pile it up like a mountain in a Halloween cauldron for the table centerpiece. It’s amazing sprinkled over ice cream for loads of crunch too.
Save
Culture and Backstory
Popcorn snack mixes have been a big deal at North American parties, especially at Halloween and in the fall. Monster Munch is just the playful version, bringing together sweet treats and fun monster looks for a new twist on the old-school snack mix you might have seen at grade school parties.
Recipe FAQs
- → Could I try another popcorn style?
Go for it! Give kettle corn or plain salted popcorn a shot. Skip the extra-buttery ones so the candy sticks better.
- → What's the best way to keep it crisp?
Throw it in a tightly sealed container on your counter. It tastes the best and stays crunchy if you munch it up in two days.
- → Is stovetop melting okay for candy melts?
Yep! Warm them slowly, stirring to keep things smooth. Don’t let it get too hot so nothing burns.
- → Don't have candy eyes, what else can I use?
Tiny chocolate chips or small round candies make cute eyes too. Just pop them on for some fun.
- → Can I prep this snack before party day?
Sure thing—make it the day before. Just let it cool all the way and keep it sealed up so it stays yummy.
- → Can I toss in other types of candy?
Absolutely! Swap in your favorite little candies or go wild with colorful sprinkles to match any celebration you’ve got.