Save
When you're in the mood for something soft and rich with a pop of crunch, these No-Fuss Easter Cookies do the trick. Every bite packs gooey middles, crisp edges, melted chocolate, and a sprinkle of those cheerful Mini Eggs. The first time I brought them to a spring fundraiser, they vanished fast—I always double the batch now!
My crew begs for these every spring. We get a kick out of snacking on dough and watching those speckled Mini Eggs get funky in the oven.
Tasty Ingredients
- Salted butter: boosts flavor depth and gives a touch of saltiness so the cookies are never dull. Go with a creamy, sweet-tasting option.
- Browned butter: makes things extra yummy with a nutty and caramelly hint. Let it get golden brown with deep specks.
- Brown sugar: keeps things chewy and moist. Light brown sugar straight from the box is perfect.
- White sugar: sweetens just right and gives the edges that crunch. Offers balance.
- Eggs: create structure and chewy texture. If you can, use large eggs brought to room temperature.
- Vanilla extract: makes it taste like a bakery. Pure stuff brings out the best.
- All-purpose flour: lays down the sturdy base and keeps them tender. Unbleached works great.
- Cake or pastry flour: for that cloud-like, soft-as-a-pillow bite.
- Baking soda: lets your edges lift and cookies spread right—check it’s fresh.
- Baking powder: gives a gentle puff for a plush cookie.
- Cornstarch: makes those centers gooey and soft.
- Semi-sweet chocolate chips: delivers classic chocolate bursts; aim for at least sixty percent cocoa for the melt factor.
- Mini Eggs: break them up—they’re the crunchy, colorful stars here. Go for new candy so the shells feel crisp.
- White chocolate chips: not required but they bring creamy sweetness—go for good quality ones if you’re adding.
Easy Steps
- Cool and Serve:
- Move cookies to a wire rack and give them five to ten minutes to cool off. They’re the best warm with a cold glass of milk. Stash extras in a sealed container to keep them tasting fresh.
- Bake:
- Let chilled dough sit out for a half-hour to soften up. Heat your oven to 350°F (175°C), line your sheet pan with parchment, roll balls, lay them out, and bake about 12 minutes—edges set, middles still look soft.
- Shape and Chill:
- Roll the dough into a long log or tube. Wrap in plastic and pop into the fridge for at least an hour (overnight works even better). That extra rest makes them taste richer and keeps them thick.
- Fold in the Chocolate:
- Stir in semi-sweet chips, broken Mini Eggs, and white chocolate chips if you want. Get everything spread out well in the dough.
- Combine the Dry Ingredients:
- Mix together both types of flour, baking soda, baking powder, and cornstarch in a separate bowl. Sift out any lumps. Add dry mix slowly to the big bowl with wet stuff—use a wooden spoon at first, then finish with your hands so everything’s blended in.
- Mix the Wet Ingredients:
- In a big bowl, toss the cooled browned butter and softened regular butter. Pour in both sugars, toss in the eggs, and splash in the vanilla, then whisk until smooth and shiny—maybe a minute. A hand mixer makes it easy but isn’t required.
- Brown the Butter:
- Drop butter into a saucepan, set it over medium, and stir until it melts and foams. Watch for dark brown bits and a nutty smell—should get golden with some brown specks in five to eight minutes. Take it off the stove and let it cool while you get the rest ready.
Save
Browning your butter changes the game—the aroma is nutty and almost caramel. Watching those Mini Eggs go soft and bright in the oven is my favorite. There’s nothing better than making these with my kids while they sneak dough by the spoonful!
Storage Solutions
For best freshness, move cooled cookies into a sealed tin or tub. Leave at room temperature up to four days. Got leftovers? Roll unbaked dough into balls and freeze—bake them later straight from the freezer and just tack on an extra minute or so in the oven.
Swaps to Try
No Mini Eggs left? Chopped chocolate bars or M&Ms work fine. Swap white chips for dark, or skip them completely. Both flours make softer cookies, but all-purpose alone still gives chewy treats, just a smidge less soft.
Fun Ways to Enjoy
These Easter cookies taste awesome with coffee or tea, make lunchboxes extra fun, and are a sweet surprise as gifts. Serve them at brunch with fresh cut fruit, or sandwich ice cream between two for a knock-out snack.
Save
Sweet Story
Chocolate chip cookies have been an American favorite since the 1930s, but adding candy eggs for spring is a fresh spin. It makes every gathering feel special. My family bakes these together right after the big egg hunt every April—they’re now a tradition!
Recipe FAQs
- → How does browned butter help cookies?
Browned butter makes these cookies smell nutty and gives them a rich, slightly toasty flavor that goes really well with sweet goodies inside.
- → What's the point of chilling the dough?
Chilling gives the tasty flavors a chance to mix together and helps the cookie dough stay thick and chewy when you bake it.
- → Can I swap out the chocolate for something else?
For sure! Use dark, white, or milk chocolate, or chop up a chocolate bar you like best—the cookies will still be awesome.
- → What's the trick for gooey middles?
Take the cookies out of the oven while the middle still looks a little soft. They'll finish cooking as they sit, and stay gooey inside.
- → Is it okay to freeze dough balls?
Go for it! Freeze the dough in balls, then bake them straight from the freezer—you just need to add a minute or two to the baking time.
- → Are Mini Eggs really needed in this dough?
Mini Eggs make these treats fun and colorful, but you can use any candy-coated chocolate—or leave them out if you want.