Save
Whenever I want a cozy, no-stress meal for friends, I whip up Hot Italian Sub Sliders. Soft buns loaded with layers of melty cheese and stacked deli meats make these perfect for chilling out on game day or lazy evenings. Each bite is oozing with flavor and cheesy goodness—no wonder everyone's always reaching for more, teens and adults alike.
I first served these sliders during a snowy board game gathering. They vanished before I even grabbed mine. Now, even the fussy eaters keep requesting them.
Tasty Ingredients
- Soft twelve count rolls (like Kings Hawaiian): get golden in the oven and stay pillowy instead of soggy
- Six ounces of ham, sliced: adds mild flavor, pick one that’s slightly smoky
- Five ounces thinly sliced salami: gives just enough spice and zing, go with the presliced kind for stacking
- Five ounces sandwich pepperoni: gives that traditional sharp taste—use large rounds for easy layering
- Nine slices of provolone: melts into everything and makes every layer creamy—fresh from the deli works great
- One third cup pickled hot cherry peppers, sliced: brings a big kick, choose bright and crunchy ones
- One third cup pepperoncini, sliced: the jarred ones with full slices stay crisp longest
- Two cloves fresh garlic, smashed: jarred won’t give you the same punchy flavor as freshly crushed
- Quarter cup melted salted butter: slather it all over the buns for golden tops, good butter makes a difference
- One teaspoon Italian herbs: this blend makes the kitchen smell like a sub shop
Easy Step-by-Step Guide
- Get the Oven Ready
- Heat your oven to 350 Fahrenheit. Let it preheat for fifteen minutes so the sliders bake evenly.
- Build Your Sliders
- Put the roll bottoms, cut side up, in a baking dish. Start with a layer of ham, then add pepperoni, then salami on top. Pile on the provolone slices, letting them overlap. Tuck in the hot cherry peppers and pepperoncini last. Place the roll tops over everything.
- Make Your Garlic Butter
- In a bowl, mix melted butter, garlic, and Italian herbs. Stir until everything smells awesome. Brush this over the tops and sides of the sliders so they’re all coated.
- Bake While Covered
- Wrap the pan in foil and bake the sliders for thirty minutes. This keeps them steamy and lets the cheese melt through without getting the bread crunchy.
- Slice to Serve
- Once baked, pull off the foil and let the pan rest a couple minutes. Use a serrated knife to cut them apart and serve right away. If you want, dip them in warm marinara for extra flavor.
Save
I’m obsessed with the pickled cherry peppers. Their sharp, tangy heat wakes up every bite. The first round I made, my youngest polished off more than anyone—they loved finding the little heat surprise in each slider.
Storage Ideas
Keep leftovers wrapped up in the fridge—they’ll stay fresh about three days. Warm them in the oven at 300 until heated through. You can also freeze the whole tray before you bake, then thaw overnight in the fridge before popping them in to cook.
Ingredient Swaps
Don’t worry if you’re out of pepperoncini or cherry peppers. Swap in mild jalapeños or banana peppers. Swiss or mozzarella work instead of provolone. For something a bit sweet, try honey ham.
Save
What Goes Well
Offer little bowls of marinara or garlicky butter for dunking. We like to have crunchy chips, tangy pickles, or crisp salads on the side. Sometimes, I make soup too—it’s awesome for dipping sliders right in.
Bit of Background
The Italian sub—sometimes called a hoagie—got its start in America thanks to Italian immigrants in the early 1900s. Turning it into pull-apart sliders brings those familiar ingredients to a warm, shareable dish for any get-together. That garlicky, herby butter on top makes the kitchen smell incredible, just like your favorite sandwich shop.
Recipe FAQs
- → Which rolls taste best for these sliders?
Squishy rolls that are easy to pull apart, like King's Hawaiian, soak up flavor and hold up nicely in the oven.
- → Can I switch up the meats?
Definitely! Try swapping in turkey, roast beef, or skip a meat altogether to fit your taste or needs.
- → Do I need both types of peppers?
Not at all—use only one kind, change up the heat, or just leave the peppers out if you want.
- → How do I make sure the sliders aren’t soggy?
Give the bottom rolls a quick toast before you build everything—that helps keep them from getting mushy.
- → How do you serve these for a group?
After baking, slice straight through the tray with a sharp knife and hand them out with a bowl of marinara for dunking.
- → Is it ok to prep them in advance?
Yep! Put them together, pop them in the fridge, then bake when you're ready for best results.