Save
Whenever I want an easy but impressive dinner that feels a little fancy, I reach for this grilled apple cider thyme chicken. The apple cider brings a cozy sweet flavor, thyme perks it all up, and grilling gives those tasty crispy bits. The marinade does all the work, leaving the chicken super tender. It’s a crowd-pleaser for cozy nights or backyard hangouts.
This dish came about during a fall when I was swimming in extra apple cider and a bunch of thyme from my garden. The first time we tasted it, everyone raved. It quickly became a must-have for our family BBQs.
Tasty Ingredients
- Chicken thighs (boneless, skinless): juicy and speedy to cook, so grab pieces similar in size for even grilling
- Fresh thyme: brings an herbal pop—go for sprigs with healthy, bright leaves
- Brown sugar: balances the tang and caramelizes the chicken nice and quick—choose soft and not clumpy
- Dijon mustard: adds slight heat and depth—pick creamy and rich Dijon
- Onion: chopped to boost flavor and add sweet notes—firm, no mushy spots
- Garlic cloves: chopped for loads of flavor—fresh, heavy cloves work best
- Apple cider: gives sweetness and a fresh apple punch—grab the fresh kind from the fridge section if you can
- Olive oil: helps everything stick and adds a little richness—choose extra virgin for more flavor
- Salt: boosts all the other flavors—fine sea salt is perfect
- Apple cider vinegar: dials down the sweetness—don’t swap for regular white vinegar
- Freshly ground black pepper: brings a mild kick—grind it right before for the best taste
Simple Cooking Steps
- Let the Chicken Rest:
- Give the just-grilled chicken a couple minutes to cool down. Top it off with lemon wedges or more thyme if you’re feeling fancy. Serve it up warm with any sides you dig.
- Char That Chicken:
- Take your chicken straight out of the marinade. Let any extra liquid drip off. Pop the thighs onto your hot grill. Cook for about eight minutes without flipping to get a good crust. Then turn them and grill for another eight. Keep an eye out for clear juices and make sure the thickest part hits one sixty five degrees Fahrenheit.
- Prep That Grill:
- Crank your grill or stovetop grill pan on medium-high. Rub a bit of oil on the grates so nothing sticks.
- Get Chicken Soaking:
- Drop your chicken thighs in with the marinade, making sure every piece gets a good coating. Press out any trapped air and seal the bag or container. Squish and turn the bag a little so everything’s mixed. Chill for at least four hours—even better if you leave it overnight.
- Make the Marinade:
- In a big zipper bag or dish, toss in garlic and onion. Pour in apple cider, olive oil, apple cider vinegar, and Dijon. Pluck the leaves off half your thyme and stir them in. Add brown sugar, pepper, and salt. Stir until smooth and everything's blended.
Save
For me, thyme is what makes this so good. Snipping it straight from my garden then tossing it on the grill always brings back summer nights. My family gathers around, piling extra thyme on before digging in.
Keep It Fresh
Pop leftover chicken into a sealed container and stash it in the fridge—lasts up to three days. Warm gently in a covered oven dish or use a nonstick skillet for quick reheating so it stays juicy. Freeze the thighs for up to two months, tightly wrapped to keep freezer burn away.
Switch It Up
No fresh apple cider? Unsweetened apple juice works too. Only got dried thyme? Use a teaspoon instead of fresh. Drumsticks or bone-in thighs are tasty as well—just grill them a little longer till they’re cooked through.
On the Side
Set this chicken over creamy mashed potatoes or have it next to roasted root veggies. Cold leftovers go great in a crisp salad with vinaigrette. Or pile up slices in a loaded sandwich with cheddar and apple for a filling lunch.
Save
Apple Cider Meets the Grill
For years, folks in the Midwest and Northeast have counted on apple cider for fall feasts. The sweet and tart marinade comes from old-school backyard cookouts I remember growing up. There’s just something about grilling with apple cider that says autumn is here and brings everyone together.
Recipe FAQs
- → What's the ideal marinating time?
Let the chicken marinate four hours at least—overnight is even better for all that flavor and tenderness.
- → Could I swap in bone-in pieces?
Absolutely! Drumsticks or bone-in thighs hold up great. Just grill them a bit longer so they cook all the way through.
- → What goes well with it?
Pair your chicken with mashed potatoes, crisp salad greens, or some roasted veggies to round out your meal.
- → How do I keep the chicken from drying out?
A good soak means juicy chicken, and grilling over medium-high heat locks in all that goodness. Rest it a few minutes before digging in.
- → Is it safe to use leftover marinade as a sauce?
Go for it, just bring that leftover marinade to a rolling boil first—it makes a bold (and safe) finishing sauce.
- → Do I really need fresh thyme?
Fresh thyme pops the most, but if you’re out, a teaspoon of dried thyme gets the job done and tastes great.