Save
This sunny Easter Dirt Cake Casserole livens up all your spring get-togethers. The combo of creamy chocolate pudding with sweet, fluffy whipped topping always brings back those times when my cousins and I would swipe gummy worms from the bowl before it hit the table. Making it is super simple, and each bite tastes like spring and reminds me of fun family days.
The first time I made this was on a chilly Easter, just searching for something tasty and cheerful. The family polished it off before dinner even started! Now every spring, they beg for it again.
Delicious Ingredients
- Cream cheese: leave it out to soften so it blends smooth Full-size blocks work nicest, way better than tubs
- Butter: unsalted gives you control over how sweet it turns out Soft is best for mixing
- Powdered sugar: gives sweetness and slides in easy Give it a sift if you want it extra smooth
- Vanilla extract: brings all the flavors together Go for real vanilla if you can
- Whipped topping: makes it airy Chill first so it holds up fluffy
- Instant vanilla pudding mix: thickens things in no time and keeps it smooth Pick a brand you love
- Milk: adds richness, helps pudding get creamy Whole is extra rich
- Chocolate sandwich cookies: smash these up for that dirt look Use fresh for the crunchiest topping
- Gummy worms: toss these over everything for a wild, colorful finish Bright ones are always extra fun
Easy How-To Steps
- Soften Dairy Ingredients:
- Let the butter and cream cheese warm up on the counter until they’re soft. Blending is much easier and it’ll come out silkier.
- Beat Cream Cheese and Butter:
- Toss your soft cream cheese and butter into a big bowl. Whip them up until they’re pale, fluffy, and no chunks left.
- Sweeten the Mixture:
- Slowly add the powdered sugar, beating until smooth and light. You want everything well mixed with no lump bits.
- Blend in Vanilla:
- Stir in the vanilla so the flavor spreads through the whole mix.
- Prepare the Pudding:
- In a different bowl, whisk your pudding mix with cold milk for a couple minutes. Wait until it’s a bit thick before moving on.
- Combine Pudding and Cream Mixture:
- Dump your thick pudding into the buttery cream cheese mix. Beat until smooth and there’s no streaks left.
- Fold in the Whipped Topping:
- With a spatula or spoon, gently swirl in the whipped topping. Stop when it’s mixed and airy.
- Crush Cookies:
- Pop the sandwich cookies in a freezer bag and give them a good smack with a rolling pin, or pulse them in a food processor for evenly chopped bits.
- Reserve Topping Cookies:
- Scoop out half a cup of crushed cookies and set aside—these go on top later.
- Mix in the Cookies:
- Gently fold in the rest of your crushed cookies into the pudding mixture. Don’t stir too hard so you still get chunky bits.
- Assemble in Dish:
- Smooth the whole batter into your casserole dish and spread it edge to edge. Make the top even.
- Finish with Cookie Topping:
- Sprinkle those saved cookie crumbs all across the top and lightly pat them down so they stick.
- Decorate with Gummy Worms:
- Arrange gummy worms on top however you’d like. You can twist or tuck a few for some extra flair.
- Chill and Set:
- Put your dish in the fridge without a cover for at least two hours. If you like it set up firmer, just leave it overnight.
- Serve and Enjoy:
- Scoop out big portions for everyone and get ready for plenty of grins.
Save
My little one always insists on putting every gummy worm in place, and the blue ones are saved just for me. That cookie crunch on top stays crisp even as the inside gets smooth and creamy—absolutely delicious.
How to store
Cover up the pan with foil or wrap once you’re done serving. Pop it in the fridge and it’ll taste fresh for up to four days. If you want those layers to settle or are making ahead, fix it the night before and it'll be spot on.
Other swaps
No chocolate sandwich cookies? You can totally use vanilla sandwich cookies or try chocolate graham crackers. For a dairy-free option, grab plant-based versions of the cream cheese, butter, and whipped topping. Almond or oat milk swaps in for regular milk really well, too.
Fun ways to share
This dessert is just right for spring brunches or Easter gatherings. Try adding pastel mini eggs, candy blooms, or colorful sugars on top. I always serve extra gummy worms because there’s never enough for the kids!
Save
Story
Dirt cake’s a favored tradition all around America, especially for kids’ parties and holidays. The Easter twist is about easy decorations and wild pops of color. Everyone gets involved, and it makes for happy, hands-on family time.
Recipe FAQs
- → What can I do to make it extra smooth?
Let the butter and cream cheese sit out to soften. Use a hand mixer so they blend into a silky mix before anything else goes in.
- → Is it possible to make this the day before?
Definitely! Build the whole thing the night ahead. The chill time overnight really blends the flavors and helps it hold its shape.
- → Got a swap for chocolate sandwich cookies?
You can use any kind of chocolate cookie. Try ones with a different flavored filling if you want to change it up a bit.
- → What’s a way to boost the cream layer’s flavor?
Mix in a dash of almond extract—or even a pinch of salt gives it a little spark. Just add to taste!
- → What are some other topping ideas?
Go wild with sprinkles, sour candies, edible grass, or sprinkle on some fresh berries if you’re after something fruity on top.